Where to Stay in St. Thomas: Top Areas for your Caribbean Vacation

Updated on July 6, 2024
by Alex Miller

St. Thomas is one of the most beautiful islands in the Caribbean, offering beaches, culture, and a wide range of accommodation options to suit every traveler. Whether you’re seeking a luxurious resort like the Ritz-Carlton or a more budget-friendly hostel, this US Virgin Island has got you covered. From the lively nightlife of downtown Charlotte Amalie to the tranquil villas of the East End, St. Thomas is quite the diverse destination. You’ll find exactly what you’re looking for – whether it’s world-class dining, jewelry stores, or a Caribbean-style beach retreat to recover from last night’s hangover.

Our pick of the best hotels in St. Thomas 🔝

With great hotels and resorts spread across the island’s top areas, deciding where to stay in St. Thomas can be a tough choice. But don’t worry, this guide will help you find the perfect base for your Caribbean vacation. We’ll cover the best neighborhoods, highlight top attractions, and provide insider tips to make the most of your stay on this slice of paradise. Let’s dive in and explore the top areas to stay during your unforgettable Caribbean getaway!

Quick Neighborhood Guide for St. Thomas 📋

  • 🏙️ For First-Time Visitors: Charlotte Amalie
  • 🌙 For Nightlife: Red Hook
  • 🌴 For Tranquil Stays: East End
  • 🏖️ For Families: Magens Bay
  • 🎣 For a Local Vibe: Frenchtown
  • 🌿 For a Peaceful Stay: Water Island

1. Charlotte Amalie – The Vibrant Capital with the Best Areas to Stay in St. Thomas 🏙️

🌟 Start here: Charlotte Amalie West is the beating heart of St. Thomas, and it’s where I recommend starting your adventure. This area is a vibrant mix of history, culture, and modern amenities, making it one of the best places to stay in St. Thomas. Whether you’re a history buff, a foodie, or just looking to soak up the local vibe, Charlotte Amalie West has something for everyone.

🏛️ Step back: Walking through the Charlotte Amalie Historic District feels like stepping back in time. The cobblestone streets and colonial architecture tell stories of the Danish past. I suggest starting your day with a visit to Fort Christian, the oldest standing structure in the US Virgin Islands. It’s a fascinating glimpse into the local history and offers some great photo ops.

Insider Tip: Don’t miss the 99 Steps, a historic staircase built by the Danes in the 1700s. It’s a bit of a climb, but the views from the top are worth it!

🍽️ Eat here: When it comes to dining, Charlotte Amalie West doesn’t disappoint. Here are some of my favorite spots:

  • Gladys’ Café: This place is a must-visit for traditional Caribbean dishes. I love their saltfish and dumplings.
  • The Greenhouse Restaurant & Bar: Perfect for a casual meal with a view of the harbor. Their seafood is always fresh.
  • Amalia Café: If you’re in the mood for Spanish cuisine, this is the spot. Their tapas are to die for.

🎉 Night fun: Charlotte Amalie West comes alive at night. The area is known for its vibrant nightlife, with plenty of bars and clubs to choose from. The Greenhouse Bar & Nightclub is a local favorite, offering live music and a lively atmosphere. If you’re looking for something a bit more laid-back, check out The Smoking Rooster for some great BBQ and cocktails.

🏞️ See this: There are plenty of attractions to keep you busy in Charlotte Amalie West. Here are a few highlights:

  • Blackbeard’s Castle: Although currently closed to the public, the exterior is still worth a visit for its historical significance.
  • Emancipation Garden: A beautiful park that commemorates the abolition of slavery in the Danish West Indies.
  • Three Queens Statue: This statue honors three women who led a successful labor revolt in 1878. It’s a powerful reminder of the island’s rich history.
  • Thomas Historical Trust Museum: Learn about the rich history and cultural heritage of St. Thomas.

Best hotels in Charlotte Amalie 🏨

⭐ Best Luxury Hotels

  • Windward Passage Hotel: This hotel located in downtown Charlotte Amalie offers an outdoor pool, free Wi-Fi, and easy access to the ferry terminal and local attractions.
  • The Pink Palm Hotel: This adults-only hotel features an outdoor swimming pool, a garden, a bar, and offers a hot tub and free private parking.

🏨 Best Mid-Range Hotels

  • Midtown Guest House: Situated in the heart of Charlotte Amalie, this guest house provides comfortable accommodations with free Wi-Fi and is within walking distance to Main Street and the ferry dock terminal.
  • Saint Thomas PO Box 6577: This property offers a variety of amenities including a swimming pool, tennis courts, and panoramic views of the Caribbean Sea.
  • The Green Iguana Hotel: Located on the north side of the island, this hotel offers a peaceful atmosphere with stunning views and is within walking distance to downtown Charlotte Amalie.

2. East End – Tranquil Villas and Apartments for a Relaxing Stay on St. Thomas 🌴

🌴 Perfect place: The East End of St. Thomas is a tranquil paradise, offering a peaceful atmosphere with stunning sea views and beautiful beaches. It’s the perfect place to unwind and soak up the Caribbean sun. Whether you’re looking for a luxury hotel or a cozy Airbnb, the East End has a variety of accommodation options to suit every traveler.

🏖️ Gorgeous views: One of the highlights of the East End is Sapphire Beach, known for its crystal-clear waters and vibrant marine life. It’s a great spot for snorkeling and diving, with plenty of opportunities to explore the underwater world. The beach is also home to a beach bar where you can enjoy a refreshing drink while taking in the gorgeous views of the Caribbean Sea.

🚤 Boat tours: For those who love adventure, the East End offers plenty of activities. You can take sailing lessons, go on boat tours around the island, or even try your hand at scuba diving. The area is also a great choice for families, with many resorts offering kid-friendly amenities and activities.

🍽️ Best Eats: The East End is also home to some fantastic dining options. From budget-friendly restaurants to gourmet dining experiences, you’ll find a variety of Caribbean cuisine to satisfy your taste buds. Red Hook is located nearby and is well connected to basically everything, making it easy to explore different neighborhoods and try out various eateries. Here are some of my favorite dining spots in the East End:

  • XO Bistro: Casual elegance with a great wine and cocktail bar.
  • SeaSalt: A rooftop restaurant with ocean-centric dining and modern techniques.
  • Pesce Italian: Fresh seafood and handmade pasta that transport you to Italy.
  • Pangea: Sustainable ocean-to-table dining with vegan and gluten-free options.

Where to stay in East End? 🏨

3. Frenchtown – Charming Fishing Village Perfect for a Unique Stay in St. Thomas 🎣

🎣 Local vibe: Frenchtown is one of those places that instantly makes you feel at home. This charming fishing village is perfect for a unique stay in St. Thomas, offering a blend of local culture, delicious food, and a laid-back atmosphere. It’s a great place to start your island adventure, especially if you’re looking to escape the more touristy spots.

🍽️ Dining area: The food scene in Frenchtown is fantastic. We love the variety of Caribbean-style restaurants and seafood joints. Here are some of my top picks:

  • Hook, Line & Sinker: A local favorite for fresh seafood and waterfront dining.
  • Oceana Restaurant & Bistro: Set in a historic building with stunning views of the cove, it’s perfect for a romantic dinner.
  • French Quarter Bistro: Offers a mix of French and Caribbean cuisine, with a cozy dining area and great cocktails.

🛥️ Yacht haven: Frenchtown is quite the spot for boating. The marina is always bustling with yachts and fishing boats, and you can even book a sailing trip or a fishing charter. It’s a great way to see the island from a different perspective and maybe even catch your dinner!

🌅 Relaxing spots: For those who prefer to sunbathe away the day, Frenchtown has some lovely spots to relax. While it doesn’t have its own beach, you’re just a short drive from Magens Bay Beach and Sapphire Bay, both of which offer stunning views and crystal-clear waters.

Insider Tip: If you’re staying in Frenchtown, consider renting a bike. It’s a fun and eco-friendly way to get around and explore the nearby areas.

🎉 Nightlife: The nightlife in Frenchtown is laid-back but lively. There are several bars and pubs where you can enjoy a drink and some live music. We recommend The Twisted Cork Cafe for its great wine selection and cozy atmosphere.

Where to stay in Frenchtown? 🏨

  • Mafolie Hotel & Restaurant: Set in tropical gardens, this hotel offers panoramic views of the Caribbean Sea and features an on-site restaurant and bar.
  • Best Western Carib Beach Resort: This beachfront resort offers a swimming pool, private beach access, and is located close to the airport, making it a convenient arrival point for all cruise ships.

4. Magens Bay – The Best Beach in St. Thomas for a Dreamy Villa Stay 🏖️

🏖️ Paradise found: Magens Bay is hands down one of the most beautiful beaches in the world, and it’s the perfect spot for a dreamy villa stay in St. Thomas. This heart-shaped bay is a true Caribbean paradise, with soft white sand, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and lush green hills surrounding it.

🌴 Tropical bliss: When you arrive at Magens Bay, you’ll instantly feel like you’ve stepped into a postcard. The beach is well-maintained, with plenty of amenities like picnic areas, showers, and beach chair rentals. But what really sets it apart is the stunning natural beauty. The sound of the waves gently lapping against the shore, the swaying palm trees, and the warm tropical breeze – it’s pure bliss.

🍽️ Dining options: While Magens Bay itself doesn’t have many dining options, you’re just a short drive away from some great restaurants. Here are a few of our favorites:

  • The Greenhouse Restaurant & Bar: Casual waterfront dining with a focus on fresh seafood.
  • Mafolie Restaurant: Set in a historic sugar mill, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience with Caribbean-inspired cuisine.
  • Flamboyan on the Bay Resort: If you’re staying at the resort, be sure to check out their on-site restaurants, which offer everything from casual beachside dining to upscale gourmet options.

🚴‍♀️ Getting around: While Magens Bay is a bit of a drive from the main towns, it’s well worth the trip. If you’re renting a villa, you’ll likely want to have a car to get around. But if you’re staying elsewhere on the island, you can always take a taxi or book a tour that includes a stop at Magens Bay.

🏞️ Outdoor adventures: Magens Bay is also a great base for exploring some of St. Thomas’s other natural attractions. You can take a short hike to the top of Drake’s Seat for panoramic views of the island, or venture out to nearby beaches like Hull Bay and Lindquist Beach.

5. Water Island – A Hidden Gem for a Secluded and Peaceful Stay on St. Thomas 🏝️

🏝️ Secluded paradise: Water Island is one of those hidden gems that offers a truly secluded and peaceful stay on St. Thomas. This small island, just a short ferry ride from Charlotte Amalie, is perfect for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle and enjoy some quiet time in paradise.

🏖️ Honeymoon Beach: One of the main attractions on Water Island is Honeymoon Beach. This beautiful beach offers soft white sand, clear turquoise waters, and plenty of shade from the surrounding palm trees.

🍽️ Dining options: While Water Island is quite small, there are still a few great places to eat. Here are some of our favorites:

  • Dinghy’s Beach Bar & Grill: Located right on Honeymoon Beach, this spot offers delicious Caribbean cuisine and refreshing drinks. It’s a great place to grab a bite to eat while enjoying the beach.
  • Heidi’s Honeymoon Grill: Another beachside option, Heidi’s serves up tasty burgers, sandwiches, and salads. The laid-back vibe and friendly service make it a favorite among visitors.

🚶‍♂️ Exploring the island: Water Island is small enough to explore on foot or by bike. There are several scenic trails that offer stunning views of the Caribbean Sea and the surrounding islands. One of the highlights is Fort Segarra, an unfinished World War II fort that provides a fascinating glimpse into the local history.

🛥️ Water activities: Water Island has plenty to offer for a bit of adventure,. You can rent kayaks, paddleboards, or even book a sailing excursion to explore the surrounding waters. The calm bays and clear waters are perfect for snorkeling and discovering the vibrant marine life.

Water Island, St. Thomas
Water Island, St. Thomas
Water Island, St. Thomas

Money Saver: The ferry to Water Island is affordable and runs regularly from Charlotte Amalie, making it an easy and budget-friendly day trip or extended stay option.

Where to stay near Water Island? 🏨

6. Red Hook – Best Place to Stay for Nightlife 🌃

🌃 Nightlife central: If you’re considering the best place to stay for nightlife in St. Thomas, Red Hook is the spot. This lively area on the East End of the island is packed with bars, restaurants, and clubs, making it the perfect choice for those who love to party and socialize.

Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas
Red Hook, St. Thomas

🍽️ Dining and drinks: Red Hook has a fantastic selection of dining options, from casual beach bars to upscale restaurants. Here are some of our top picks:

  • Duffy’s Love Shack: A legendary tiki bar known for its fun atmosphere, creative cocktails, and delicious bar food.
  • Fish Tails Bar & Grill: Offers fresh seafood and stunning views of the marina, perfect for a relaxed dinner.
  • XO Bistro: A more upscale option with a great wine list and a menu that features a mix of Caribbean and international dishes.

🎉 Party spots: When the sun goes down, Red Hook comes alive with music and dancing. Here are a few places you shouldn’t miss:

  • Molly Molone’s: An Irish pub with live music and a lively crowd, perfect for a fun night out.
  • Island Time Pub: Known for its laid-back vibe and great views, this spot is ideal for a more relaxed evening.
  • Tap & Still: A popular bar with a great selection of craft beers and a fun, casual atmosphere.

Insider Tip: If you’re planning to hop between bars, consider using the local safari taxis. They’re an affordable and convenient way to get around Red Hook.

🚤 Marina views: One of the best things about Red Hook is its beautiful marina. During the day, you can watch the yachts and boats come and go, and even book a sailing excursion or a fishing trip. It’s a great way to see the island from a different perspective and enjoy the stunning views of the Caribbean Sea.

🛍️ Shopping and more: In addition to its nightlife, Red Hook has plenty of shops and boutiques where you can find everything from local crafts to high-end jewelry. It’s a great place to pick up souvenirs or treat yourself to something special.

Where to stay in Red Hook? 🏨

  • Sugar Mill Hotel, Tortola: Located on Tortola, this picturesque hotel features a private beach, on-site dining, and is set in a historic sugar mill.
  • Casa Cielo, St. Thomas: This luxury villa offers panoramic views, a private swimming pool, and is the perfect setting for a relaxing getaway.

FAQs about Visiting St. Thomas ❔

Which area of St. Thomas is the best to stay in?

Downtown Charlotte Amalie is often recommended as the best area to stay in St. Thomas due to its central location and proximity to top attractions

Which side of St. Thomas has better beaches?

The East End of St. Thomas is known for having some of the best beaches, including Sapphire Beach and Lindquist Beach.

Is it better to stay in St John or St. Thomas?

It depends on your preferences: St. Thomas is better for nightlife, shopping, and dining, while St. John is ideal for nature, hiking, and a more peaceful atmosphere.

What are the safest areas in St. Thomas USVI?

Charlotte Amalie, East End, and Magens Bay are considered some of the safest areas in St. Thomas.

Can I get around St. Thomas without a car?

Yes, you can get around St. Thomas without a car using taxis, dollar taxis, and public transportation, although having a car can provide more convenience.